Tooth Extraction Cost on St. Simons Island: Simple, Surgical, and Who Does Which
Key Takeaways
Tooth extraction cost on St. Simons Island depends mostly on whether the tooth comes out easily or requires surgery: a simple extraction averages $162 in Georgia, and a surgical extraction averages $363 nationally before sedation.
- Simple extraction: $177 national average ($137 to $335), $162 in Georgia, per CareCredit’s 2024 cost study. Local anesthesia is included.
- Surgical extraction: $363 average ($281 to $702). Deeper wisdom tooth impactions average $423 to $835 per tooth.
- All four wisdom teeth: about $2,685 nationally and $2,846 in Georgia before sedation, which averages $349.
- A standard dental implant averages $4,344, so a pulled molar that is not a wisdom tooth costs more to replace than to remove.
If you have been searching for tooth extraction cost on St. Simons Island, you have probably found pages that stop before giving a number. This article gives the numbers, from simple and surgical extractions to wisdom teeth removal cost, nitrous oxide, and what an empty socket costs later. Dentistry in Redfern in St. Simons Island, GA performs both simple and surgical extractions, including impacted wisdom teeth, in its Redfern Village office, so “who does which” has a short answer here.
How Much Does a Tooth Extraction Cost in St. Simons Island, GA?
A simple tooth extraction averages $162 in Georgia and $177 nationally, while a surgical extraction averages $363, according to CareCredit’s 2024 cost study. Those fees include local anesthesia but not the exam, X-rays, or sedation.
The national averages come from CareCredit’s 2024 cost study, which reports a national range of $137 to $335 for a simple extraction and $281 to $702 for a surgical one. The same study notes that dental schools charge 60% to 70% less than private practices.
The extraction fee covers the extraction and the numbing injection. It does not cover the exam and X-ray that confirm the tooth needs to come out, any sedation you choose, or whatever replaces the tooth afterward.
Dentistry in Redfern does not publish a fee schedule, so treat these figures as benchmarks; the number for your tooth comes from an exam and X-ray and is included in a written treatment plan before anything is removed.
| Type of extraction | National average | Typical range |
|---|---|---|
| Simple extraction Erupted tooth, removed with forceps |
$177 | $137 to $335 |
| Surgical extraction Incision, bone removal, or sectioning |
$363 | $281 to $702 |
| Soft tissue impaction Wisdom tooth partly under the gum |
$423 | $325 to $829 |
| Full bony impaction Wisdom tooth fully in bone |
$532 | $413 to $1,041 |
| Complicated impaction Angled tooth under bone and gum |
$835 | $639 to $1,620 |
Source: CareCredit 2024 Cost Study, per tooth, local anesthesia included. Georgia average for a simple extraction: $162.
Simple vs. Surgical Extraction: What Is the Difference and Who Does Which?
A simple extraction removes a visible tooth with an elevator and forceps. A surgical extraction opens the gum, removes bone, or sections the tooth to remove it. Dentistry in Redfern performs both in-house and out-of-house procedures, including impacted wisdom teeth.
A simple extraction (also called a closed or routine extraction) is what most people picture: the tooth is fully erupted, the dentist numbs the area, loosens it with an instrument called an elevator, and lifts it out with forceps. Cleveland Clinic estimates 30 to 60 minutes per tooth.
A surgical extraction (also called an open extraction) is needed when forceps cannot do the job: a tooth broken off at the gumline, curved roots, a decayed tooth that crumbles, or any impacted tooth (one trapped under gum or bone). The dentist opens the gum, may remove a little bone, and may section the tooth, and stitches often follow, which is why surgical extractions cost more and heal more slowly.
Why a simple extraction can turn surgical
A simple extraction can become surgical mid-appointment if a decayed crown fractures under the forceps, leaving the roots to be removed surgically. It is the most common reason a bill exceeds the quote. Dentistry in Redfern uses a 3D cone beam CT scanner that shows root position and bone volume, a flat X-ray cannot, so you know beforehand which type you are likely to need.
Who does what the part most extraction pages leave vague. Cleveland Clinic notes that general dentists usually refer complex extractions to specialists. Dentistry in Redfern is set up differently: its dentists perform simple and surgical extractions, including badly decayed teeth and impacted wisdom teeth, in the same Redfern Village office, which means one exam, one scan, and one fee.
How Much Does Wisdom Teeth Removal Cost in St. Simons Island?
Wisdom teeth removal cost in Georgia averages $2,846 for all four teeth before sedation, compared with $2,685 nationally, according to CareCredit. A single impacted wisdom tooth averages $325 in Georgia, and deeper impactions run $423 to $835 per tooth.
Wisdom teeth (third molars) are priced tooth by tooth, and the price follows how deeply the tooth sits. CareCredit’s wisdom teeth cost guide puts the average for all four at $2,685 nationally and $2,846 in Georgia, rising to $3,340 if all four are complicated impactions. An erupted wisdom tooth is priced like any surgical extraction, around $363, and CareCredit’s impacted wisdom tooth guide lists Georgia’s average for an impacted one at $325.
The American Dental Association notes that wisdom teeth usually appear between the ages of 17 and 21 and that a dentist takes an X-ray before recommending removal.
Why does age change the price?
Cleveland Clinic explains that many dentists recommend removal in the late teens or early 20s because the teeth are still developing, which makes them easier to extract. That is why the typical wisdom teeth patient here is a Glynn Academy or Frederica Academy senior, a College of Coastal Georgia student home on break, or a Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers trainee at Glynco who wants to be healed before flying home. Austin Brown, DDS, grew up in the Golden Isles and attended Glynn Academy, so timing the procedure around exams and summer jobs is a familiar conversation in his chair.
Dentistry in Redfern removes impacted wisdom teeth in its own office under local anesthesia, with nitrous oxide available, and a same-day call about a wisdom tooth that has flared up is a familiar part of the schedule, which is one reason the office reserves time each day for emergency patients.

Is Nitrous Oxide Available for Tooth Extractions at Dentistry in Redfern?
Yes. Dentistry in Redfern offers nitrous oxide (laughing gas) for in-house extractions, including surgical and wisdom-teeth extractions. Local anesthesia is included in the extraction fee; ask about the nitrous fee when you receive your written treatment plan.
Nitrous oxide is a mild sedative that is mixed with oxygen and inhaled through a small nasal mask. The American Dental Association describes it as a safe and effective way to relax without being put to sleep: you stay awake, you can answer questions, and the effects wear off soon after the mask comes off. For most patients, it takes the edge off the sounds and pressure of an extraction.
Nitrous oxide is also the least expensive sedation. CareCredit’s cost study groups nitrous with oral and IV sedation at an average of $349, and general anesthesia at an average of $639.
Does Dental Insurance Cover Tooth Extractions?
Most dental plans cover 50% to 70% of the cost of a medically necessary tooth extraction, according to CareCredit. Complex wisdom tooth surgery can sometimes be billed to medical insurance as well, and a pretreatment estimate shows what each plan will pay.
CareCredit puts typical dental coverage at 50% to 70% after the deductible, which turns a $363 surgical extraction into roughly $109 to $182 out of pocket. Your annual maximum matters more than the percentage when four wisdom teeth land in one plan year.
Wisdom teeth are a special case. Delta Dental explains that difficult wisdom tooth extractions can sometimes be billed to medical insurance, and that a pretreatment estimate sent to one or both insurers is the best way to learn what you will owe.
What does a tooth extraction cost without insurance?
Without insurance, a simple extraction in Georgia runs about $162 per tooth and a surgical extraction about $363 per tooth, plus the exam and X-rays; all four wisdom teeth average $2,846 before sedation, per CareCredit. Dentistry in Redfern accepts traditional dental insurance, files claims to get the most from your benefits, and offers patient financing, so an uninsured patient can spread the cost over monthly payments.
Why Does the Cheapest Extraction Often Become the Most Expensive Gap?
Pulling a tooth is the cheapest procedure that day, but an unreplaced molar can cause neighboring teeth to shift and bone to shrink, and replacement costs far more than extraction. A standard dental implant averages $4,344 per tooth, per CareCredit.
Here is the honest paragraph most extraction pages skip. The American Dental Association notes that the average adult between 20 and 64 already has three or more decayed or missing teeth, and that remaining teeth may shift, and bone loss can occur around a missing tooth. A root loads the jawbone; remove it and the bone shrinks, which is why the Cleveland Clinic says a dentist may place a bone graft in the socket at the time of extraction.
Now the replacement math. CareCredit’s cost tables list a standard endosteal (endosseous) dental implant at $4,344 per tooth, so a $162 extraction followed by an implant is a four-figure decision. That is why the root canal cost article on this site argues that saving a restorable tooth usually costs less over time, and why the implant vs. bridge comparison belongs before the extraction, not after.
“The fee people ask about is the extraction, and for a simple one it is a small number,” says Zachary Powell, DMD at Dentistry in Redfern in St. Simons Island, GA. “What I want settled before we pull anything is what happens to the space. For a wisdom tooth, nothing. For a first molar, usually an implant, and the 3D scan we take before a surgical extraction tells us whether that socket will hold one. Doing the extraction and the planning in one office means one plan and one price instead of a handoff.”
Wisdom teeth are the exception. Nobody replaces a third molar, so wisdom teeth removal cost is the whole cost. For every other tooth, the extraction fee is the down payment.
What Should You Expect on Extraction Day and During Recovery?
A single extraction takes 30 to 60 minutes, and most people return to routine activities within 48 to 72 hours, per Cleveland Clinic. Wisdom teeth patients should plan three to five days at home and two weeks to recover.
The appointment runs the same way whether it's simple or surgical: numbing, loosening, and removing the tooth, cleaning the socket, stitches if needed, and gauze to help form the blood clot. Cleveland Clinic calls day three the worst day for pain and lists over-the-counter ibuprofen or acetaminophen among the options for managing it. A molar socket can take up to four months to fill in, which is why an implant is usually placed after a few months.
The ADA’s extraction guidance says to skip straws for 24 hours, avoid smoking and vigorous rinsing, and stick to the soft diet your dentist suggests, because dislodging the clot causes dry socket (alveolar osteitis), which exposes bone and is painful. For FLETC trainees and students timing a procedure around travel, Cleveland Clinic’s three to five days at home after wisdom teeth removal is the number to plan around.
Dr. Powell has practiced on the Georgia coast for more than 25 years, 15 of them on St. Simons Island, and a tooth that needs to come out today is not a rare event in a practice that age.
Who Should Have a Tooth Pulled at Dentistry in Redfern, and Who Should Think Twice?
Dentistry in Redfern is the right call for simple extractions, surgical extractions of broken or decayed teeth, and impacted wisdom teeth, done in-house with nitrous oxide available. A restorable tooth or symptom-free wisdom teeth deserve a conversation first.
Three groups should book without second-guessing: anyone with a tooth that cannot be fixed with a filling, crown, or root canal; a teen or young adult whose X-ray shows impacted or crowded wisdom teeth, since removal gets harder with age; and anyone in pain today, because an emergency room will usually treat the pain and send you to a dentist anyway.
Two groups should slow down. Cleveland Clinic’s position is that providers prefer to save natural teeth whenever possible, and the root canal cost article above shows why a restorable tooth usually costs less to save than to replace. If your wisdom teeth are in, aligned, and causing no trouble, the ADA says they can be kept and monitored at regular visits.
Dentistry in Redfern is privately owned and non-corporate, part of the Georgia Smile Group, which Dr. Powell leads as CEO and Chief Dental Clinician, and the exam, extraction, and replacement plan all happen under one roof at 288 Redfern Village.
Schedule an Extraction Consultation at Dentistry in Redfern
If a tooth needs to come out, the fastest way to get a real number is an exam and X-ray at Dentistry in Redfern, 288 Redfern Village on St. Simons Island. Call (912) 638-9090 or request an appointment online, and ask for a written plan that covers the extraction, nitrous if you want it, and what replaces the tooth.
Dentistry in Redfern is a dentist on St. Simons Island providing comprehensive, patient-focused dental care for families across the island and nearby Golden Isles communities. We are committed to helping patients achieve healthier, more confident smiles through personalized treatment and advanced dental technology.
Read Patient Reviews | Meet Our Dental Team | Schedule Your Appointment
